| 2010 Season |
| WR: Jacques Mackeroy - Second Team Defense |
| WR: Aaron Baysdon - Third Team Offense |
| WR: Jarvis Washington - Honorable Mention Offense |
| RB: Terry Bentley - Honorable Mention Offense |
| QB: Isaac O'Neal - Honorable Mention Offense |
| OL: Savion McKenzie - Honorable Mention Offense |
| TE: Kerwin Harrison - Honorable Mention Offense |
| K: Omar Carvajal - Honorable Mention Offense |
| DL: Malcom Andrews - First Team Defense |
| LB: Gionni Paul - First Team Defense |
| DB: Victor Troutman - First Team Defense |
| ATH: Terrick Colston - First Team Defense |
| DL: Javon Brown - Third Team Defense |
| DL: Otis Buford - Honorable Mention Defense |
| DB: Jarvier Maturin - Honorable Mention Defense |
| LB: Danzell Zinermon - Honorable Mention Defense |
| LB: Diego Wilson - Honorable Mention Defense |
| DL: Fred Leonard - Honorable Mention Defense |
| LB: Marcel Bruce - Honorable Mention Defense |
| 2009 Season |
| QB: Isaac O'Neal - Second Team Offense |
| WR: Marcus Cunningham - Second Team Defense |
| WR: Brayun Andrews - Second Team Offense |
| RB: Terry Bentley - Third Team Offense |
| WR: Jacques Mackeroy - Third Team Offense |
| OL: Austin Hancock - Third Team Offense |
| K: Javier Rodea - Third Team Offense |
| WR: Carson Varney - Honorable Mention Offense |
| OL: Trey Clark - Honorable Mention Offense |
| DL: Malcom Andrews - First Team Defense |
| LB: Andrew Jackson - First Team Defense |
| DB: Chad Abrams - First Team Defense |
| DL: Otis Buford - Second Team Defense |
| LB: Gionni Paul - Second Team Defense |
| LB: Terrick Colston - Third Team Defense |
| DL: Javon Brown - Honorable Mention Defense |
| DL: John Barnes - Honorable Mention Defense |
| DL: Alvin Williams - Honorable Mention Defense |
| DB: Julani Harper - Honorable Mention Defense |
| DB: Victor Troutman - Honorable Mention Defense |
| DB: Derek Lewis - Honorable Mention Defense |
| 2008 Season |
| WR: Marcus Cunningham - Second Team Offense |
| DL: Kerron McKenzie - Second Team Defense |
| QB: Isaac O'Neal - Honorable Mention Offense |
| WR: Jacques Mackeroy - Honorable Mention Offense |
| WR: Brayun Andrews - Honorable Mention Offense |
| DB: Chad Abrams - Honorable Mention Defense |
| DB: DeAndre Callaway - Honorable Mention Defense |
| LB: Terrick Colston - Honorable Mention Defense |
| LB: Gionni Paul - Honorable Mention Defense |
| LB: Andrew Jackson - Honorable Mention Defense |
| DL: Marqueze Kirby - Honorable Mention Defense |
| DL: Junior Perez - Honorable Mention Defense |
| DL: Malcom Andrews - Honorable Mention Defense |
| 2005 Season |
| OL: Jimmie Andrews - First Team Offense |
| DL: Ja'Michael Highsmith - First Team Defense |
| DB: T.J. Lawrence- First Team Defense |
| QB: Dominique Davis - Second Team Offense |
| WR: Adrian Smith - Second Team Offense |
| K: Clint Slappey - Second Team Offense |
| RB: Terrell Colston - Honorable Mention Offense |
| OL: Zach Garcia - Honorable Mention Offense |
| WR: Brandon Davis - Honorable Mention Offense |
| WR: Darrel Henley - Honorable Mention Offense |
| LB: Sylvester Buford - Honorable Mention Defense |
| LB: Jeremy Edinger - Honorable Mention Defense |
| LB: Mondrell Clark - Honorable Mention Defense |
| DB: Le'Var Thompson - Honorable Mention Defense |
| DB: Antwon Murray - Honorable Mention Defense |
| 2004 Season |
| RB: Marcus Okobi - First Team Offense |
| OL: Jimmie Andrews - First Team Offense |
| DL: Albert McClellan - First Team Defense |
| LB: Trent Newton - First Team Defense |
| LB: Scott Bryant - First Team Defense |
| DL: Tyrell Robinson - Second Team Defense |
| LB: Ed Taylor - Second Team Defense |
| DB: Ahmad Black - Second Team Defense |
| QB: Antoine McRoy - Honorable Mention Offense |
| WR: Kenneth Bess - Honorable Mention Offense |
| DL: Darrell Lake - Honorable Mention Defense |
| DB: Ronnie Callaway - Honorable Mention Defense |
| 1995 Season |
| K: Paul Edinger - First Team Offense |
| TE: Carver Donaldson - Second Team Offense |
| UT: Freddie Mitchell- Second Team Offense |
| DL: Chris Campbell - Second Team Defense |
| OL: Trent Lawhon- Honorable Mention Offense |
| QB: Jason Spiro - Honorable Mention Offense |
| RB: Victor Stewart - Honorable Mention Offense |
| RB: LaQuient Knight - Honorable Mention Offense |
| LB: Charles Martin - Honorable Mention Defense |
| LB: Earl Miller - Honorable Mention Defense |
| DB: Andrae Shaw - Honorable Mention Defense |
| 1993 Season |
| DL: Tommy Lane - First Team Defense |
| WR: Daymion Robins - Honorable Mention Offense |
| TE: Michael Norman - Honorable Mention Offense |
| QB: Desmond Clark - Honorable Mention Offense |
| K: Derek Otstot - Honorable Mention Offense |
| LB: Rod Crockett - Honorable Mention Defense |
| LB: Demetrius Windham - Honorable Mention Defense |
| DB: Rashad Robinson - Honorable Mention Defense |
| DB: Alphonso Taylor - Honorable Mention Defense |
| 1992 Season |
| OL: Zedric Dunn - First Team Offense |
| K: Lance Privett - First Team Offense |
| LB: Ray Lewis - First Team Defense |
| DL: Tommy Lane - Second Team Defense |
| LB: Steve Franklin - Second Team Defense |
| WR: Travis Houston - Honorable Mention Offense |
| OL: Danny McCall - Honorable Mention Offense |
| QB: Jason Mitchell - Honorable Mention Offense |
| RB: Kendrick Bridges - Honorable Mention Offense |
| LB: Rod Crockett - Honorable Mention Defense |
| DB: Alphonso Taylor - Honorable Mention Defense |
| 1991 Season |
| DL: John Battle - First Team Defense |
| DB: Torrian Gray - First Team Defense |
| OL: Shawn Pruitt - Second Team Offense |
| RB: Patrick Haggins - Second Team Offense |
| LB: Ray Lewis - Second Team Defense |
| WR: Paul Clark - Honorable Mention Offense |
| QB: Arnold McFarlane - Honorable Mention Offense |
| RB: Carlos McCalpin - Honorable Mention Offense |
| P: Scott Jones - Honorable Mention Defense |
| 1987 Season |
| QB: Eric Gallon - First Team Offense |
| DL: Duan Jones - First Team Defense |
| RB: Aubrey Bell - Second Team Offense |
| DL: Jeffrey Harris - Second Team Defense |
| DL: Larry Laster - Second Team Defense |
| WR: Ernest Craft - Honorable Mention Offense |
| OL: Brian Bell - Honorable Mention Offense |
| RB: Eric Gant - Honorable Mention Offense |
| RB: Chris McAfee - Honorable Mention Offense |
| DL: Richard Seay - Honorable Mention Defense |
| DB: Malcolm Everette - Honorable Mention Defense |
| P: Eric Harden - Honorable Mention Defense |
| 1982 Season |
| OL: Chris Franklin - First Team Offense |
| DL: Daryl Blow - First Team Defense |
| LB: Brian Martin - First Team Defense |
| DB: Vic Riddle - First Team Defense |
| DL: Jessie Lanier - Second Team Defense |
| WR: John Williams - Honorable Mention Offense |
| QB: Pat Pinner - Honorable Mention Offense |
| DL: Ronnie Bates - Honorable Mention Defense |
| DB: Gerald Taylor - Honorable Mention Defense |
| 1974 Season |
| QB: Rick Plank - First Team Offense |
| LB: Chet Miller - First Team Defense |
| LB: Ed Corbin - First Team Defense |
| WR: Reginald Owens - Second Team Offense |
| DL: Tony Borders - Second Team Defense |
| RB: Reese King - Honorable Mention |
| Kenny Davis - Honorable Mention |
| Manny White - Honorable Mention |
| Kenny Squire - Honorable Mention |
| Mark Scruggs - Honorable Mention |
| 1973 Season |
| QB: Rick Plank - First Team Offense |
| WR: Nelson Taylor - First Team Offense |
| DB: Reginald Owens - First Team Defense |
| P: David Ashley - First Team Defense |
| RB: Lee Lewis - Second Team Offense |
| TE: Jeff Garland - Second Team Offense |
| DL: Tim Moore - Second Team Defense |
| DL: John Brady - Second Team Defense |
| LB: Gerald Taylor - Second Team Defense |
| DB: Maurice Sheals - Second Team Defense |
| 1971 Season |
| WR: Willie Cook - First Team Offense |
| LB: Frank Pennachio - First Team Defense |
| DB: John Milnor - First Team Defense |
| QB: Danny Muchler - Second Team Offense |
| WR: Luke Peterson - Second Team Offense |
| WR: Tony Browning - Second Team Offense |
| OL: Leon Goodman - Second Team Offense |
| OL: Will Callahan - Second Team Offense |
| DL: Elmer Fortson - Second Team Defense |
